UPDATE: The state of the European economy

Recently, Europe’s economy has avoided appearing on many of our news screens what with other international affairs such as Russia/ Ukraine, Syria and Iraq in the headlines for probably my entire summer holidays. But that doesn't mean that the European economy is all hunky-dory and the recession is a thing of the past.

This post is an update of what is actually going on in Europe right now, giving you three key case studies: Italy, France and Germany.

Italy

·      Triple dip recession – GDP fell by 0.2% in the second quarter of 2014

·      12.6% unemployment rate

·      43% youth unemployment

·      Little political will to do anything about it

France

·      Rising budget deficit

·      Last quarter’s GDP growth: 0%!

·      Chance of going back into recession, was also 0% in the quarter before last

Germany

·      GDP fell 0.2% in the last quarter, the first GDP contraction this year

·      Manufacturing sector slow down

·      Geopolitics is affecting growth: Russia’s embargo on European food imports is apparently affecting 9.5m European farmers, and is affecting Germany’s trade

Key points to note about Europe right now:

·      Low inflation.

Average Euro Area: 0.4%

Deflation in 8 Eurozone countries including the PIGS (Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain)

Country in Eurozone	Inflation rate
France	0.4%
Italy	-0.1%
Germany	0.8%
Spain	-0.5%
Greece	-0.3%
Portugal	0.4%

Why is this a problem?

·           Increases the real value of debt which means that government debt increases making it harder to pay off and increasing the likelihood of needing another bail out

·           Taxes will have to rise eventually to fund the increased debt accumulation which means businesses will have a higher tax burden à leaving some Eurozone countries

·           There is danger of falling into a deflation trap where prices just keep falling. This is called a deflation spiral.

·      High unemployment

·      High government debt

·      Political upheaval

·      Geopolitics with Russia

·      Lack of political union

Different countries in the Eurozone want different things and have different views with how situations should be handled, e.g. with Russia, which makes it hard to manage economic policy and introduce austerity measures where needed.

What can be done?

·           Keep interest rates low – increasing interest rates will just decrease inflation more

·           “Quantitative Easing lite”: the European Central bank buys assets to stimulate the economy and help inflation rise

Anything else?

·           Role of competition in markets:

o   There was a period of very low inflation during the late 19^th century in Germany and the UK

o   Analysis shows there was competition in markets and businesses operated in a competitive environment

o   Competition restricts wage growth because there are many companies in the same industry offering the same job and the same wage. This is happening now!!!

o   A competitive market means that firms are unwilling to increase the price of goods and services – preventing inflation from rising. This is happening now!!!

o   It is therefore hard to increase inflation. This is happening now!!!

Michael Portillo's 'Great Euro Crisis'

On BBC2 on Wednesday night was a very information documentary about the Eurozone crisis, in particular Greece. You can watch it here on BBC iplayer. Remember it won't be there forever, do take time to watch it.


Summary:

• One quarter shops have closed since the crisis began in 2008
• Social costs: Graffiti everywhere, dereliction
• Michael Portillo's view is that Greece's joining the euro created the crisis
• Introduction of the Euro: purpose - to help the poorer European countries catch up to their richer counterparts
• The Euro has made Greece uncompetitive, considering the Drachma was weak and this helped fuel demand for their exports
• The Euro also increased the amount of exports entering the country, particularly cars (what made it easier was the wide availability of credit for Greeks to finance the purchase of these cars)
• In 6 years, Greece's deficit from Germany went up from under €3bn to over €8bn
• Another contribution to the debt: transport advancements (equipment could not be manufactured in Greece, so had to be imported by German companies) were paid for with debt, and tax evasion
• Devaluing the currency (going back to the Drachma) can help improve their competitiveness
• Government put national assets (e.g. the airport) among other austerity measures, to try to save the country

Fiscal Policy video

Paj Holden's video on fiscal policy is a great material for revision or learning fiscal policy from scratch.

Key points/summary of topics explained

Fiscal policy - manipulating government spending and taxation levels in order to manage the level of AD in the economy.

Definition of AD (C+I+G+X-M)

In a weak economy (low AD), the government might consider loosening fiscal policy - lower taxes (boost consumption) and increasing government spending. Disadvantage of loose fiscal policy, if spending becomes too high, deficits rise, creating problems, such as the Eurozone crisis.

Explains the Euro crisis

Business cycle and output gaps

Note: The AD/AS diagram he uses shows the Keynesian LRAS (notes to come!)

Case Study: Greece

---> GDP growth of -6.6%

---> Budget deficit (2009) was 15% of GDP. In 2010, it was 11% of GDP and in 2011 it was 8% as a result of increased taxes and lower government spending (austerity measures). However the Greek government is still spending 8% more than revenues gained from taxation. There is also interest gained from the additional spending, demonstrating the importance of their fiscal constraints.


Quantitative Easing

Bad News for Britain

The UK's budget deficit (amount by which government expenditure is in excess of tax revenues) rose above £1 trillion (£1,000,000,000,000!) for the first time, in December 2011. This spells bad news for us because:

1. It means the government's deficit reduction plan is not working, which could mean deeper cuts for the rest of 2012.

2. The Eurozone crisis

Use this as a case study for what happens if the government uses Keynesian policies to increase economic growth (Labour's government policies....). Unemployment rose the same time as the deficit reaches an all time high, evidence for crowding out?